Milagro Restaurant & Bar
Make Milagro One of Your Go-To Old Town Key West Restaurants
Milagro is one of the family-owned old town Key West restaurants known for scratch-made Latin and Caribbean cooking, handcrafted cocktails, and warm, attentive service. Run by Executive Chef Kevin Montoya and General Manager Maggie Montoya, we are committed to giving every guest a memorable meal in an intimate, welcoming setting.
Right on Duval Street, in the Heart of Old Town
Milagro is two blocks from the Southernmost Point of the continental USA, with Mallory Square, the Historic Seaport, and the cruise port all a short walk away. The dining room is intimate, with original artwork on the walls and indoor and outdoor seating, plus a bar that fills up most nights. Locals tell their friends about Milagro before any of the other restaurants on Duval Street.
Dinner, Cocktails & Happy Hour
Dinner
Cocktails & Tequil
Happy Hour
Tuesday through Saturday, 5 to 9 PM. The menu blends Latin, Mexican, and Caribbean flavors, prepared by a chef trained in Michelin-starred kitchens.
With a name like Milagro, you know we take tequila seriously. The tequila menu is long, the flights are generous, and the bar also pours a thoughtful wine list, cold beer, and craft cocktails made with fresh-squeezed juice and house-infused spirits. It is one of the cocktail bars in Old Town Key West worth a stop on its own.
Tuesday through Saturday, 5 to 6:30 PM. Sample our favorites with small-plate specials and Buy 1, Get 1 drinks at the high-tops. It is the best happy hour this side of the Southernmost Point.
Things to Do in Old Town Key West Before or After Dinner
Old Town Key West offers a memorable walk in any direction. A few stops worth fitting in before or after dinner at Milagro:
01
Sunset at Mallory Square:
About a 15-minute walk. This is a Key West tradition!
02
The Southernmost Point:
Just two blocks away. Snap a quick photo before your reservation.
03
A walk down Duval Street:
enjoy galleries, shops, and live music up and down the strip.
04
Historic Seaport and Key West Bight:
about 20 minutes on foot, with boats, sunset views, and another round of cocktails.
05
Live music after dinner:
Duval Street is full of bars and venues to continue the evening.
For many of our guests, dinner at Milagro is part of the evening. We are honored to be one of the restaurants in Old Town Key West that our guests return to again and again.
