overhead image of the grilled octopus appetizer at Milagro Restaurant & Bar

FINE DINING,
KEY WEST STYLE

A CULINARY EXPERIENCE

Fresh, Local & Eclectic Dining In the Heart of Old Town, Key West

Milagro Restaurant & Bar Menu

Key West Caribbean & Latin Cuisine

The Milagro Restaurant & Bar menu brings scratch-made Latin, Mexican, and Caribbean food to 821 Duval Street. Chef Kevin Montoya, Michelin-trained, turns fresh ingredients, local seafood, and tropical produce into a refined dining experience. Dinner runs Tuesday through Sunday, 5–9 PM.

Book a Table

Our passion for tequila is obvious from our extensive menu. Order by the glass or try a flight to compare and contrast styles. All cocktails, beer, and bottles of wine and liquor are available for carry out.

By The Glass

CLASE AZUL

CASAMIGOS

Blanco | Reposado | Anejo | Mezcal

KOMOS

Anejo Cristalino | Reposado Rosa | Extra Anejo

TEARS OF LLORANA

Extra Anejo

MAESTRO DOBEL

Cristalino | Reposado

EL CORAZON

Anejo

EL TESORO

Reposado | Extra Anejo

512

Anjeo

21 SEEDS

Valencia Orange

ASOMBROSSO

Silver | Reposado | Extra Anejo

LOA AMANTES

Joven Mezcal

CINCORO

Blanco | Reposado | Anejo | Gold | Extra Anejo

Blanco | Anejo

HERRADURA

Silver | Ultra Anejo | Selección Suprema Extra Anejo | Anejo Legend

LA ADELITA

Blanco | Reposado | Anejo | Cristalino

CASA DRAGONES

Joven

EL MAYOR

Reposado | Extra Anejo

RIAZUL

Anejo 80

MONTELOBOS

Mezcal

TRES AGAVE

Reposado | Anejo

SAUZA

Silver | Gold

DON JULIO

1942 Anejo | Blanco | Double Cask Reposado | Reposado Primavera

AVION

Extra Anejo Reserva 44 | Cristalino Reserva

PATRON

Silver | Reposado | Anejo | Café

LOBOS

Extra Anejo

CASA NOBLE

Reposado

MILAGRO SELECT BARREL

Silver | Reposado | Anejo

OCHO

Reposado

HORNITOS

Anejo

818

Anejo

VOLANDO

Mezcal

Flights

MAGGIES'S FAVORITE

Clase Azul Reposado | Herradura Legend Anejo | Tears of LLorona Extra Anejo | Clase Azul Ultra

CLASE AZUL

Plata | Reposado | Gold | Anejo

EL CORAZON

Casa Noble Reposado | Avion Extra Anejo Reserva 44 | Komos Anejo Cristalino | Don Julio 1942 Anejo

MILAGRO

Milagro Silver Select Barrel | Casamigos Reposado | Lobos Extra Anejo | Casa Dragones Joven

FRIDA

Clase Azul Reposado | Don Julio Reposado Primavera | Komos Anejo Cristalino | Riazul Anejo

CINCORO

Blanco | Reposado | Anejo | Extra Anejo

AMIGOS

CREATE YOUR OWN FLIGHT

Pick 4 or 8 tequilas of your choice and ENJOY

A Mexican Restaurant in Key West with Caribbean Soul

Chef Kevin layers Mexican technique with Caribbean island flavor. Al pastor marinades, fresh-pressed tortillas, and smoked chiles meet plantains, citrus, and tropical produce from the region.

Scratch-Made, Locally Sourced

Fine dining starts in the kitchen. Snapper, hogfish, shrimp, and stone crab come off the local fleet. Sauces, salsas, tortillas, and stocks are made in-house, daily. Fresh ingredients and tropical produce, regional when the season allows. The Milagros menu changes with what comes in.

Compliment Your Meal With Tequila or a Craft Cocktail

The bar pours one of the deepest tequila selections in Key West, with flights for tasting blanco, reposado, and añejo. Craft cocktails use fresh-squeezed juice and house syrups. The wine list runs Old World to New, curated to pair alongside the food rather than overshadow it.

Bar Menu