top of page
overhead image of the grilled octopus appetizer at Milagro Restaurant & Bar

In-House Scratch Cooking That's...

FRESH, LOCAL & ECLECTIC

​

Enjoy an elegant, adult-dining experience filled with fresh ingredients, local seafood, and tropical produce. 

fine dining, Key West style.

Milagro excels at

DINNEROur menu is a take on fine dining, Key West style and features sophisticated, eclectic seafood dishes and meat entrees with Latin, Mexican, and Caribbean flavors.
FIRST
PETITE FILET MIGNON & KWP SHRIMP
Thyme Roasted Fingerling Potatoes | Cabernet Demi
TOASTED CUMIN AHI TUNA CRUDO
Escabeche Cucumber | Guajillo Mayo | Pepitas
WOOD GRILLED OCTOPUS
Applewood Bacon Polenta | Dried Tomato Vinaigrette
CHICKEN THIGH PASTOR TACOS
Smoked Pineapple Salsa | Tomatillo Salsa
CHILLED KEY WEST PINK SHRIMP
Salsa Maria Rosa | Lemon & Black Salt
MILAGRO MEATBALLS
Roasted Tomato Salsa | Queso Fresco
SEARED FILET TIPS
Cilantro Chimichurri | Chipotle Crema
CRISP FRIED CALAMARI
Charred Jalapeño Aioli | Cotija
WARM ASIAGO BREAD
Whipped Sea Salt Butter
SOUP & SALAD
ROASTED ORGANIC BEET SALAD
Arugula | Tangerine | Crumbled Goat Cheese | Candied Walnuts | Roasted Shallot Vinaigrette
CAESAR
Crisp Romaine | Brioche Croutons | Grana Padano | Champagne Dressing
ICEBERG WEDGE
Applewood Bacon | Gorgonzola | House Buttermilk Dressing
CLASSIC FRENCH ONION
Aged Gruyere | Caramelized Onions | Spanish Sherry
ENTREES
TWIN TENDERLOIN MEDALLIONS & FLORIDA LOBSTER TAIL
Prosciutto & Parmesan Potato Cake | Port Demi
DOUBLE BONE CHESHIRE PORK CHOP
Grain Mustard Rub | Maple Sweet Potatoes | Whiskey Demi
WOOD GRILLED RIBEYE STEAK
Garlic Mashed Potatoes | Gorgonzola Scallion Compound Butter
CRACKED PEPPER SWORDFISH STEAK
Parmesan Jasmine Rice | Lemon Caper Butter
PAN SEARED KWP SHRIMP & SCALLOPS VERACRUZ
Saffron Lime Risotto | Golden Raisin Olive Relish | Tomato Broth
STACKED BLUE CORN ENCHILADAS
12 Hour Braised Angus Brisket | Fontina | Hatch New Mexico Red Chile
TOASTED PINE NUT PESTO FETTUCCINI
Asparagus | Roasted Seasonal Mushrooms | Tomato Coulis
BELL & EVANS BONE-IN CHICKEN BREAST
Smoked Bacon Mac & Cheese | Natural Thyme Jus
SEARED HOGFISH
Citrus Rice | Pomegranate Mango Salsa | Lemon Creme
DAILY FEATURE
Your server will inform you of today's special dish

join our mailing list

FINE DINING,
KEY WEST STYLE

A CULINARY EXPERIENCE

In the Heart of Old Town, Key West

bottom of page